Most people in the state of Alabama probably know who Hoover High School is. For those that aren’t, go back and watch the MTV show Two-A-Days.. They have been called Hoover U for a long time. They have won multiple state championships, received much national recognition and been featured on ESPN and MTV, of course.
In the last few weeks and months, a grade changing scandal has taken hold at Hoover. When the report was released, it said the following:
- Some football players received preferential academic treatment. One administrator has been reassigned over this.
- There is a need for tighter controls of finances for Hoover football camps and broadcasts.
- The coach, Rush Propst, has been providing income for a second family.
- Accusations that Propst had an affair with a former assistant principal were “hardly baseless.” This is the same assistant principal that was reassigned for the grade changing.
Additionally, in the aftermath of these allegations, you hear stories from people inside Hoover and out that generally give you the picture that Propst is not all that great a guy. Profanity laced tirades to players, that kind of thing.
Add that to Hoover’s propensity over the years for players from other high schools to transfer to Hoover, at a high frequency, and you start to get a picture, clouded though I’m sure it still is from the outside, that things are not well with the football program there.
Many people in Birmingham and Hoover are calling for changes, for Propst to be fired or reassigned. And I have to say at this point I agree. I don’t see anything redeeming about him. I don’t see anything but a boat anchor at this point, sinking fast. It’s just the right thing to do. And I assumed most people would agree.
But, alas, in the south, winning is more important than character. It started for me when a former player two years removed called Paul Finebaum last week, and begun spouting about how Rush was his role model and how he had taught his players how to be men. When Finebaum rightly challenged him on exactly what Propst taught, given these allegations and the kind of person most people see Propst as, the player responded by saying he had two championship rings, and that he thought this was all a dirty scheme by Spain Park High School and Vestavia Hills to take Hoover down.
What???
Then today, 65 players delivered a letter of support for their coach. That’s admirable. It would have been something great in a movie such as ‘Remember the Titans’, where a black coach was mistreated because of his race. This is different altogether and honestly these kids are misguided and blinded by being part of the Hoover U machine. I can’t really blame them.
What makes me angry is that when someone from the Hoover School Board basically called the parents out in the situation for caring about winning more than character, the parents and players got upset, and even accused the school board member of, again, wanting to cause harm to Hoover because her child attended Spain Park.
Look people. This isn’t a scheme to destroy the mighty Hoover machine. This isn’t people in Birmingham who just can’t put up with your success. Me personally? I enjoyed the run Hoover has been on. I rooted for the state championships. I wanted them on ESPN. I think building such a success is great. And I even run laps around the football field, with the state of the art field turf… it’s great.
But that’s not what this is about. It’s not jealousy. It’s not about your rings or your MTV show or the ESPN game of the week. It’s about 65 high school kids that believe in their heart that this man is their role model. This man that has a second family, likely had something to do with the grade changing issue through the now removed assistant principal he was having an affair with, prefers language that causes people to carry their kids away from the practice field, and who knows what else, a few things that I’ve heard second or third hand, and probably much more I’m not aware of because I am nowhere near close to the program…
This man is not a role model. You are confused. You’ve confused winning with becoming a man. It’s not the same thing. This man taught the 65 of you how to win at football… apparently at great cost if necessary. I’m sorry that it’s gone this way, but character is more important than winning, and that’s going to last long past your time at Hoover.
And as for the parents that are buying into this… take a minute and look at what this coach has done. Think about if this was happening in your home.. or in your family.. or in your church. And yet, because he has won a lot of games, you gloss it over, and continue to let your children think that this is the ok way to handle yourself in a high profile position? Shame on you for caring more about winning a football game on Friday night than the example set by the coach of your team. Are you guys serious??
Propst has to go. He should already be gone. Perhaps Mike Price can hire him on his staff at UTEP. Somebody needs to step up and stand up for character being more important than winning, and it needs to happen soon.
If anyone is reading and would like to comment further feel free..



